Series: Lorcana
Whispers in the Well Release Date: November 14, 2025
Set Abbreviation: WITW
Lorcana’s newest set may have just missed Halloween, but it's still jam-packed with spooky cards. It also brings new characters from The Gargoyles and The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad to the game. Let's look at the highest value cards you can hope to pull when opening the latest set!
Download the Rare Candy App to start scanning and tracking all of your Lorcana hits.
10. Malicious, Mean, and Scary (Enchanted) - $103.16
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #231
Up next is a song card from Tangled’s classic song: “I’ve Got a Dream”. Which is actually the perfect thing to sing while trying to pull it. True fans will also notice a small continuity error in the art: Hook Hand’s hook is on the wrong arm!
9. Webby Vanderquack - Junior Prospector (Enchanted) - $122.25
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #229
Ducktales is back to bring us more lovable characters in Whispers in the Well. Webby utilizes the green ‘jealousy’ mechanic but this time for the number of cards in the opponent’s inkwell. Timing will be critical when playing this card.
8. Can't Hold It Back Anymore (Enchanted) - $130.27
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #228
It can’t be a top 10 list without a card featuring Elsa! Can’t Hold it Back Anymore is of course another song card from the iconic hit: “Let It Go.” The swirls and ice crystals give it a really stunning look!
7. The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow (Enchanted) - $131.63
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #232
Coming in at #7 is the iconic villain from The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad. It’s as hard to forget seeing this character in the movie as it will be to forget the feeling of opening this card in a pack. The flaming jack-o’-lantern is a hauntingly bold centerpiece of the art.
6. Spooky Sight (Enchanted) - $148.89
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #237
Another spooky card from The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad. Cards that feature the classic Disney trio of Goofy, Mickey, and Donald are sure to remain popular. You’ve got to love that blending of classic animation and modern art.
5. Demona - Scourge of the Wyvern Clan (Enchanted) - $159.88
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #227
Number 5 first character on this list from The Gargoyles and it packs a punch! The enchanted treatment makes any card eye-catching but the vibrant green and yellow smoke along with the purple wisps really stands out on this one.
4. Goliath - Clan Leader (Enchanted) - $185.96
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #238
Number 4, also from The Gargoyles, features the Clan Leader himself: Goliath. As the leader, this steel card does his best to prepare his fellow gargoyles for action. By keeping hand sizes to 2, your gargoyles will wake up from their “Stone By Day” and ready before you draw your card for the turn.
3. Cinderella - Dream Come True (Enchanted) - $310.45
Rarity: Enchanted
Card Number: #238
Cinderella really breaks out from the pack here on value. It makes sense, considering she is a fan favorite with breathtaking art that really shows off the enchanted treatment. She is also getting a lot of attention in the Constructed side of the game as she ramps your ink and draws you another card on her own. Getting to do it more is just a bonus if you can play more princesses.
2. Ariel - Ethereal Voice (Iconic) - $562.99
Rarity: Iconic
Card Number: #241
We can pretty much expect the iconic cards to come in at the top spots of any set given how hard they are to find. Rest assured, when you pull one you will be happy no matter which one you get. If only she had a singer ability, letting her sing songs of higher value, she might have seen more play in Constructed.
1. Hades - Looking for a Deal (Iconic) - $619.45
Rarity: Iconic
Card Number: #242
At the top of the list is the Lord of the Deal: Hades. Usually, giving your opponents a choice in battle means you get the worst option. Being as valuable as he is, Ravensburger can print any ability they want on him. Final rating: “Two thumbs way, way up.”
What’s next for these cards:
Card values will continue to stabilize as more packs are opened, but you can still expect some shifting in the order as favorites work their way to the top.
Breakout cards in tournaments that shake up the meta can also cause cards that aren’t even on this list to rise up if players want to make their decks look extra shiny for big tournaments.
While we have only seen 4 iconic cards, their rarity likely means they will remain the most valuable cards in any set they are printed in.
Download the Rare Candy App to start scanning and tracking all of your Lorcana hits.
